Shield Nickels — Key Dates, Values & the First American Nickel
1866–1883 • With Rays & Without Rays • The Proof-Only 1877 & 1878
Shield Nickel Value Guide
Key Dates and Typical Values by Grade
| Date / Type | Mintage | Good (G-4) | VF-20 | MS-63+ |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1866 With Rays — First Year | ~14,742,500 | $25 | $80 | $500+ |
| 1867 With Rays | 2,019,000 | $30 | $150 | $1,500+ |
| 1867 With Rays — Proof | ~25 known | Excessively rare | $100,000+ | |
| 1867–1876 Without Rays (common) | Varies | $15 | $50 | $300+ |
| 1877 — Proof Only | ~510 | $8,000 – $30,000+ | $40,000+ | |
| 1878 — Proof Only | 2,350 | $3,000 – $12,000+ | $18,000+ | |
| 1880 — Great Lull Key | 16,000 | $2,500+ | $6,000+ | $25,000 – $100,000+ |
| 1881 | 68,800 | $400+ | $1,200+ | $10,000+ |
Origins of the Shield Nickel
The Shield Nickel, authorized by the Act of May 16, 1866, was the first American five-cent coin actually struck in a copper-nickel alloy — introducing the metal that would give the entire denomination its lasting nickname. Designed by James B. Longacre, the same engraver behind the Indian Head Cent and several other mid-19th-century U.S. coin designs, the obverse features a heraldic shield representing strength and unity, topped with a cross and flanked by crossed arrows, while the reverse shows a large numeral 5 encircled by stars.
The new coin's introduction created an unusual overlap: the silver half dime, which had represented the same five-cent value since 1792, continued circulating alongside the new copper-nickel coin for several years, since Congress had not yet formally discontinued it. Nearly 15 million Shield Nickels were struck in the first year alone — partly to promote the new coin quickly, and partly because copper and nickel were far more available and affordable than the silver required for half dimes. The half dime was finally discontinued for good with the Coinage Act of 1873, leaving the Shield Nickel as the sole five-cent coin until it was itself replaced by the Liberty Head Nickel in 1883.
With Rays and Without Rays — A Mid-Series Redesign
The original 1866 and early 1867 design included rays — small decorative lines radiating between the stars surrounding the reverse's large numeral 5. This detail proved to be a genuine manufacturing headache: the added design elements increased striking pressure requirements, causing dies to crack and fail far more often than the Mint could tolerate. In mid-1867, officials ordered the rays removed entirely, creating two distinct varieties within the same year — 1867 With Rays and 1867 Without Rays — that collectors treat as separate, both necessary, dates for a complete type set.
Even with the rays removed, the Shield Nickel remained a notoriously difficult coin to strike well throughout its entire 17-year run. The series is known among specialists for inconsistent strikes, frequent die cracks, and generally weak detail compared to other coinage of the era — meaning that even common dates in genuinely sharp, well-struck Mint State condition command real premiums over typical circulated examples.
The "Great Lull" — 1877 to 1881
By the mid-1870s, the channels of commerce were already saturated with Shield Nickels — in fiscal year 1877 alone, the Mint received over 7.1 million worn nickels back for redemption and simply reissued millions of them rather than striking new ones. This created what specialists call the "Great Lull": a five-year stretch from 1877 through 1881 during which the Mint either drastically reduced or completely halted new nickel production, defining the entire key-date structure of the series.
The results were dramatic. In 1877 and 1878, no business strikes were produced for circulation at all — every genuine example from either year is a proof coin, struck specifically and only for sale to collectors. The 1880 saw just 16,000 business strikes, the lowest circulation mintage in the entire series, while 1881 wasn't much better at 68,800. These five years, taken together, define the true challenge of assembling a complete Shield Nickel date set — far harder than the series' relatively brief 17-year run might otherwise suggest.
Key Dates and Major Rarities
1877 — Proof Only
1878 — Proof Only
1880 — The Great Lull's Peak
1867 With Rays Proof
1881
1866 With Rays — First Year
Shop Shield Nickels on eBay
Browse common With Rays and Without Rays dates to certified key dates including the proof-only 1877 and 1878.
Shield Nickel References on Amazon
Where to Buy Shield Nickels
These are the marketplaces and resources used by serious Shield Nickel collectors for buying and research.
eBay
eBay — Key Dates
JM Bullion
Kitco
Money Metals Exchange
SD Bullion
Silver Gold Bull
FRC Coin Price Guide
Related Coin Guides
Find These Coins on eBayMoney Back Guarantee
FindRareCoins.com participates in the eBay Partner Network and Amazon Associates program. Purchases made through links on this page may earn us a commission at no additional cost to you.
Frequently Asked Questions
What is the most valuable Shield Nickel?
The 1880 is generally considered the most valuable and difficult regular-issue date, with only 16,000 business strikes produced — the lowest circulation mintage in the entire series. However, the proof-only 1877 (only about 510 struck) and the excessively rare 1867 With Rays proof (only about 25 known) are arguably even more significant rarities in absolute terms, since no business strikes of 1877 exist at all and the 1867 proof rarity is exceptionally scarce.
What is the difference between 1867 With Rays and Without Rays?
The original 1866 and early 1867 design included small decorative rays radiating between the stars on the reverse, surrounding the large numeral 5. This design proved to cause serious striking problems — the extra detail required more pressure and caused dies to crack and fail prematurely. In mid-1867, Mint officials ordered the rays removed entirely, creating two distinct varieties within the same calendar year that collectors treat as separate, both-required dates for a complete type set.
Why are 1877 and 1878 proof-only years?
By the mid-1870s, so many Shield Nickels were already circulating that the Mint faced a genuine oversupply — in fiscal year 1877 alone, over 7.1 million worn nickels were returned for redemption, and the Mint simply reissued millions of them rather than striking new coins. As a result, no business strikes were produced in 1877 or 1878 at all; every genuine example from either year is a proof coin, struck specifically and only for sale to collectors, not for circulation.
What is the "Great Lull" in Shield Nickel history?
The "Great Lull" refers to the five-year period from 1877 through 1881, during which the U.S. Mint drastically reduced or completely halted new Shield Nickel production due to an oversupply already circulating in commerce. This period produced the series' defining key dates: the proof-only 1877 and 1878, plus the extremely low circulation mintages of 1880 (16,000) and 1881 (68,800). Understanding the Great Lull is essential to understanding why the Shield Nickel series is genuinely challenging to complete despite its relatively short 17-year run.
Should I buy raw or certified Shield Nickels?
For any key date — especially the 1877, 1878, 1880, or 1867 With Rays proof — PCGS or NGC certification is strongly recommended. The Shield Nickel series is notorious for weak, inconsistent strikes even on genuine coins, which can make grading difficult for non-specialists, and the extreme values of the true key dates make authentication essential for any significant purchase.
What is a good entry point for collecting Shield Nickels?
Common-date Without Rays nickels from the late 1860s and early-to-mid 1870s in Good to Fine condition offer the most accessible entry point, typically available for $15–$50. From there, collectors typically pursue the 1866/1867 With Rays type coin before working toward the Great Lull-era dates, treating the 1877, 1878, 1880, and 1881 as milestone acquisitions that define a genuinely complete Shield Nickel collection.
A Guide Book of Buffalo and Jefferson Nickels,. Market Values & Mintages – Includes updated retail pricing, mintage data, specifications, and coverage of Full Steps Jefferson nickels.
The Complete Guide to Shield and Liberty Head Nickels. Features enlargements for important overdates and other varieties, plus actual-size photographs of every coin in the Shield and Liberty Head series.
'
