Barber Dimes — Key Dates, Values & the Legendary 1894-S
1892–1916 • 90% Silver • Liberty Head Design • The Famous "Ice Cream" Dime
Barber Dime Value Guide
Key Dates and Typical Values by Grade
| Date / Mint | Mintage | Good (G-4) | Fine (F-12) | VF-20 | MS-63 |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Common date (P) | Varies | $3 | $6 | $12 | $150+ |
| 1895-O | 440,000 | $500+ | $1,200+ | $3,000+ | $25,000+ |
| 1896-S | 575,056 | $150+ | $350+ | $700+ | $8,000+ |
| 1901-S | 593,022 | $120+ | $300+ | $600+ | $7,000+ |
| 1903-S | 613,300 | $100+ | $250+ | $500+ | $8,000+ |
| 1913-S | 510,000 | $60+ | $150+ | $300+ | $4,000+ |
| 1894-S — The Legend | 24 (proof only) | $1,000,000 – $2,340,000+ | Only 9 known | ||
Origins of the Barber Dime
The Liberty Head Dime — known to every collector as the Barber Dime — was struck from 1892 to 1916, part of the complete redesign of America's silver coinage undertaken by Chief Engraver Charles E. Barber. All three "Barber coinage" denominations — dime, quarter, and half dollar — debuted simultaneously in 1892, sharing the same obverse portrait of Liberty wearing a laurel wreath and cap. The dime occupies a unique place in this trio: while its quarter and half-dollar siblings each have their own legendary rarities, the dime is home to arguably the single most famous small-denomination rarity in all of American numismatics.
The series arrived during the same artistic push that replaced the long-running Seated Liberty design across the dime, quarter, and half dollar denominations. Struck across four mints — Philadelphia, New Orleans, San Francisco, and Denver in the series' final years — the Barber Dime offers collectors substantial date-and-mint variety, anchored by a genuine set of demanding key dates that go well beyond the famous 1894-S.
Design and Mint Marks
The obverse presents Liberty in profile, wearing a Phrygian cap and laurel wreath, with "LIBERTY" inscribed on a headband and thirteen stars surrounding the portrait — identical in concept to the Barber Quarter and Half Dollar designs from the same artist. The reverse carries a simple wreath encircling the denomination, a more restrained composition than the eagle reverses used on its larger siblings, appropriate to the dime's smaller diameter. Mint marks appear on the reverse below the wreath: no mark for Philadelphia, "O" for New Orleans, "S" for San Francisco, and "D" for Denver.
As with the Barber Quarter, mint mark placement drives dramatic value differences within the same date — nowhere more famously than 1894, when the Philadelphia and Denver mints struck ordinary quantities while San Francisco struck just two dozen proof examples never intended for wide circulation.
The 1894-S — America's Most Famous Small Coin
In the first half of 1894, the San Francisco Mint struck just 24 dimes bearing the "S" mint mark — every single one a proof coin, none intended for general circulation. Why so few were made remains a genuine, unresolved numismatic mystery. Competing theories include a bookkeeping adjustment to balance a $2.40 discrepancy in the Mint's books, a small batch of test strikes to check die quality, or coins struck as personal favors. No single explanation has ever been definitively confirmed.
The most famous account — often called the "ice cream story" — holds that San Francisco Mint Superintendent John Daggett struck the coins as gifts for banker friends and gave three to his young daughter, Hallie, instructing her to set them aside until she was old enough to appreciate their value. According to the story, first documented decades later, Hallie spent one of the three on a dish of ice cream on the walk home, unaware of what she was holding. Numismatic historians treat this tale as beloved but unverified lore rather than confirmed fact — the earliest written accounts trace to secondhand retellings, not contemporary 1894 documentation. Whatever the true origin, only nine 1894-S dimes are known to survive today, including two heavily circulated examples — one of which turned up in a junk coin box at a New York department store in 1957 and sold for just $2.40, only to later realize $33,000 at auction in 1989. Certified examples in better condition have sold for well over $1 million at multiple auctions in the 2000s and 2010s.
Key Dates and Major Rarities
1894-S — The Legend
1895-O
1896-S
1901-S & 1903-S
1913-S
1892 — First Year
Shop Barber Dimes on eBay
Browse common Philadelphia dates to certified key dates — the 1894-S is a genuine numismatic treasure, always buy certified from a reputable major auction house or dealer.
Barber Dime References on Amazon
Where to Buy Barber Dimes
These are the marketplaces and resources used by serious Barber Dime collectors for buying and research.
eBay
eBay — Key Dates
JM Bullion
Kitco
Money Metals Exchange
SD Bullion
Silver Gold Bull
FRC Coin Price Guide
Related Coin Guides
Find These Coins on eBayMoney Back Guarantee
FindRareCoins.com participates in the eBay Partner Network and Amazon Associates program. Purchases made through links on this page may earn us a commission at no additional cost to you.
Frequently Asked Questions
What is the most valuable Barber Dime?
The 1894-S is the undisputed king of the series and one of the most famous coins in all of American numismatics — only 24 were struck at the San Francisco Mint, all as proofs, and just 9 examples are known to survive today. Certified examples have sold for well over $1 million at multiple major auctions, with some estimates placing current values above $2 million for the finest known specimens.
Is the "ice cream story" about the 1894-S dime true?
It's beloved numismatic lore, but not confirmed historical fact. The story holds that San Francisco Mint Superintendent John Daggett struck the 24 coins for banker friends and gave three to his daughter Hallie, who allegedly spent one on a dish of ice cream on the walk home. The tale first appeared in later secondhand accounts rather than contemporary 1894 documentation, and numismatic historians generally present it as legend rather than established history. What is documented is that only 24 coins were struck and just 9 survive — the reason why remains a genuine, unresolved mystery with several competing theories.
What is the "Ice Cream Specimen" 1894-S dime?
One of the nine known 1894-S dimes is a heavily circulated example, graded Good-4, that was discovered in a junk coin box at a New York department store in 1957 and purchased for just $2.40 — its face value at the time. This particular coin became known as the "Ice Cream Specimen," a nod to the famous legend, and later sold at auction for $33,000 in 1989, illustrating the dramatic appreciation of even the roughest surviving example of this rarity.
What are the other key dates in the Barber Dime series?
Beyond the legendary 1894-S, the 1895-O (440,000 struck) actually has the lowest mintage of any regular-issue Barber Dime and is a formidable rarity in its own right, often overshadowed by its more famous sibling. The 1896-S, 1901-S, 1903-S, and 1913-S round out the series' meaningful semi-key dates, all with mintages well under a million and genuine scarcity in higher grades.
Should I buy raw or certified Barber Dimes?
For any Barber Dime key date — and absolutely for anything claiming to be an 1894-S — PCGS or NGC certification from a reputable source is essential. Given the extraordinary value of the 1894-S, counterfeits and fraudulently altered dates or mint marks are a serious documented risk. Never purchase a purported 1894-S without ironclad certification and, ideally, a documented auction provenance given how few genuine examples exist.
What is a good entry point for collecting Barber Dimes?
Common-date Philadelphia and San Francisco Barber Dimes in Good to Fine condition offer the most accessible entry point, typically available for $3–$12. From there, most collectors work toward completing a full date-and-mint set, treating the 1895-O, 1896-S, and other semi-keys as milestone acquisitions before ever considering the 1894-S — a coin that realistically sits outside the budget of all but the most advanced or well-resourced collectors.
From the earliest 1792 Half Disme to the modern Roosevelt and Semiquincentennial issues, this book explores the evolution of the dime in remarkable detail.
'
