Nickel Error Coins: Most Valuable Types & What They're Worth
Nickel error coins span more than a century of U.S. Mint history — from the legendary 1937-D Three-Legged Buffalo to War Nickel overdates and modern Jefferson doubled dies. Some are worth $30 in pocket change. Others have sold for thousands at auction.
Collector's Value Guide
Why Nickel Errors Are Worth Collecting
The five-cent piece has a longer and more varied error history than almost any other U.S. denomination still in circulation today. Between the Buffalo Nickel's hand-finished dies, the Jefferson Nickel's eight-decade production run, and the wartime switch to a silver alloy from 1942 to 1945, nickels have produced some of the most famous error coins in the entire hobby — including one variety collectors specifically search rolls for by name.
Nickels are also less heavily searched than cents, meaning genuine errors still surface in circulation and bank rolls at a higher rate than you'd expect. A complete set of nickel errors by type and series — Buffalo, Jefferson, and War Nickel — is a rewarding long-term collecting goal at almost any budget.
Quick value benchmark: Most nickel error coins in circulated condition are worth $15–$150. Dramatic errors (major doubled dies, off-center strikes, wrong planchet) on desirable dates like the 1937-D Three-Legged Buffalo or War Nickel overdates regularly reach $300–$5,000+ at auction in any grade.
Buffalo Nickel Error Coins (1913–1938)
The Buffalo Nickel (also called the Indian Head Nickel) is home to the single most famous error coin in American numismatics. Its short 25-year run, combined with hand-finished dies at the Denver Mint, produced a concentration of dramatic and valuable errors unmatched by almost any other short series.
1937-D Three-Legged Buffalo
A Denver Mint employee over-polished a die to remove clash marks, accidentally grinding away the bison's front leg. The single most famous error coin in the Buffalo Nickel series and one of the most recognized errors in all of U.S. numismatics.
$400–$10,000+ Rare
1918/7-D Overdate
A 1917-dated working die was re-punched with 1918 numerals, leaving the underlying 7 visible beneath the 8. One of the most desirable overdates in the entire Buffalo Nickel series.
$1,000–$25,000+ Rare
1914/3 Overdate
A less famous but genuine overdate variety where 1913 die numerals were re-punched with a 1914 date, leaving traces of the earlier digit. Scarcer in higher grades.
$150–$2,000+ Scarce
Doubled Die Obverse
Multiple Buffalo Nickel dates show hub doubling on LIBERTY, the date, or the Indian's profile. The most dramatic examples show clear separation visible without magnification.
$75–$2,500+ Rare
Off-Center Strikes
Buffalo Nickels struck 25%+ off-center with the date visible are genuinely scarce given the series' age. The bison and Indian profile designs make significant off-center examples highly visual.
$150–$2,000+ Rare
Repunched Mint Marks
Denver and San Francisco Buffalo Nickels used hand-punched mint marks — repunching was common on several dates in the 1920s and 1930s. Many RPM varieties are catalogued and collected.
$20–$300+ Common
Die Cracks & Cuds
Late-die-state Buffalo Nickels with prominent die cracks and rim cuds are actively collected as terminal die state specimens, particularly on lower-mintage dates.
$25–$400+ Common
Wrong Planchet
Buffalo Nickel dies striking cent or foreign planchets produce dramatically undersized or off-color coins. Authentication is mandatory for any claimed example.
$500–$5,000+ Rare
Buffalo Nickel Error Values by Grade
| Error Coin | VG-8 | VF-20 | EF-40 | MS-63 | Shop |
|---|
| 1937-D Three-Legged KEY | $400 | $700 | $1,200 | $5,000+ | eBay → |
| 1918/7-D Overdate KEY | $1,000 | $2,500 | $5,000 | $25,000+ | eBay → |
| 1914/3 Overdate | $150 | $300 | $600 | $2,000+ | eBay → |
| Doubled Die Obverse | $75 | $200 | $500 | $2,500+ | eBay → |
| Off-Center Strike (25–50%) | — | $150 | $300 | $2,000+ | eBay → |
Shop Certified Nickel Errors
Browse PCGS and NGC certified Buffalo, Jefferson, and War Nickel error coins with current market prices.
Free Coin Value Estimator
Affiliate links — FindRareCoins.com may earn a commission when you purchase through links on this site.
Jefferson Nickel Error Coins (1938–Present)
The Jefferson Nickel has been struck continuously since 1938, making it one of the longest-running U.S. coin designs in production. Its sheer volume — often hundreds of millions per year — means that even rare error rates on modern dates still produce a meaningful population of survivors for collectors to find.
1939 Doubled Monticello
Strong doubling is visible on the word MONTICELLO and the steps of the building's reverse design. One of the most recognized and actively collected Jefferson Nickel doubled die varieties.
$50–$800+ Scarce
Full Steps (FS) Designation
Not an error itself, but a strike-quality designation for Jefferson Nickels showing 5 or 6 fully separated steps on Monticello. FS-designated coins command significant premiums over non-FS examples of the same date.
$25–$1,500+ Scarce
Doubled Die Obverse
Multiple Jefferson Nickel dates show doubling on the date, LIBERTY, or Jefferson's portrait. Certified examples with strong, clearly separated doubling command the best premiums.
$25–$600+ Scarce
Off-Center Strikes
Jefferson Nickels struck 20–50% off-center with the date visible are among the more common and affordable modern nickel errors. Most circulated examples fall in the $30–$150 range.
$30–$500+ Common
Broadstrikes
Struck without the retaining collar, the planchet spreads outward producing a coin with no rim that's thinner and wider than normal. A great entry-level error for new collectors.
$15–$100+ Common
Wrong Planchet
Jefferson Nickel dies striking cent or foreign planchets produce dramatically undersized or wrong-colored coins. Authentication is mandatory for any claimed example.
$200–$2,000+ Rare
2005 "Speared Bison"
A die gouge on the Westward Journey bison reverse creates the appearance of a line piercing the animal's body. A widely known and actively collected modern die variety.
$15–$100+ Common
Lamination Errors
Impurities or trapped gas in the planchet metal cause a thin layer of the coin's surface to peel or flake away, exposing a rough or pitted area beneath. Genuine examples show a clean separation, not damage.
$15–$150+ Common
War Nickel Error Coins (1942–1945)
From mid-1942 through 1945, the U.S. Mint replaced the standard copper-nickel alloy with a 56% copper, 35% silver, and 9% manganese composition to conserve nickel for the war effort. War Nickels are the only regular-issue five-cent pieces ever struck in silver, and they're immediately identifiable by a large mint mark — P, D, or S — placed above Monticello's dome, the first time the Philadelphia Mint ever used a P mint mark on U.S. coinage.
1943/2-P Overdate
A 1942-dated die was re-punched with 1943 numerals, leaving remnants of the underlying 2 visible beneath the 3. The best-known overdate variety in the War Nickel series.
$75–$1,200+ Rare
Doubled Die War Nickel
Several War Nickel dates show hub doubling on the large mint mark above Monticello or on the date. The oversized mint mark makes doubling especially easy to spot.
$50–$800+ Scarce
Off-Center Strikes
War Nickels struck 25%+ off-center with the date visible are scarce given the short four-year run. Silver content adds a value floor beneath the error premium.
$150–$1,500+ Rare
Wrong Planchet (Pre-War Alloy)
A small number of War Nickel dies struck coins on leftover standard copper-nickel planchets rather than the wartime silver alloy — an error verified by weight and a magnet test rather than appearance alone.
$500–$3,000+ Rare
Silver melt value note: War Nickels (1942–1945) contain 0.0563 oz of pure silver each. At current prices, the silver melt value alone is typically $2–$3 per coin. Error coin value sits entirely on top of this baseline. Use the
Silver Coin Melt Calculator to check current melt values before buying or selling.
How to Find Nickel Error Coins
Bank Roll Hunting
Jefferson Nickels are still readily available as $2 face value rolls from most bank branches. Nickel rolls are significantly less picked-through than cent or quarter rolls, which means genuine errors — including doubled dies, off-center strikes, and the Speared Bison variety — are still found by patient hunters. Request rolls directly from bank tellers for the freshest, least-searched material.
Estate Sales and Coin Show Lots
Buffalo Nickels and War Nickels rarely appear in circulation today but surface regularly at estate sales, coin shows, and dealer junk-box lots. Searching a group of circulated Buffalo Nickels for the three-legged variety or an overdate is a legitimate strategy — many sellers price common-date Buffalos on bulk value alone, leaving error premiums on the table.
What to Examine Under Magnification
For Buffalo Nickels, check the bison's front legs first — a genuinely missing leg (not just a weak strike) is the 1937-D key variety. For Jefferson Nickels, check MONTICELLO and the steps for doubling using a 5×–10× loupe, and count the steps for Full Steps quality. For War Nickels, check above Monticello's dome for a large, doubled, or re-punched mint mark.
Confirming vs. Post-Mint Damage
Nickels are prone to bag marks, scratches, and rim dings from normal handling — these are not errors. A genuine mint error shows clean, undisturbed coin surfaces around the anomaly, since the flaw happened before or during striking, not after. A worn or damaged bison leg from circulation wear is not the same as the 1937-D die-polishing error, which shows a complete, clean absence of the leg with no ragged edges.
Grading Nickel Error Coins
Nickel error coins are graded on the standard Sheldon 1–70 scale with the error described separately. A PCGS or NGC label for a significant nickel error will show the grade (e.g., MS-63) alongside the error description (e.g., "Three-Legged" or "Doubled Die Obverse").
For any nickel error likely worth $200 or more, professional grading is strongly recommended. PCGS and NGC both have strong track records authenticating Buffalo, Jefferson, and War Nickel varieties and errors. Their certified holders protect the coin and make it significantly easier to sell at fair market value.
Getting the most from certification: Submit Full Steps Jefferson Nickels and doubled die varieties to PCGS's VarietyPlus program or NGC's VarietyPlus equivalent. These programs specifically attribute the variety on the holder, which adds measurable value over a generic date-and-mint designation.
Where to Buy & Research Nickel Coins
Trusted marketplaces and resources for buying, selling, and researching Buffalo, Jefferson, and War Nickels.
JM Bullion
Trusted bullion dealer carrying War Nickel silver bags and rolls. Free shipping on orders over $199.
Visit JM Bullion →
Kitco
Live silver spot prices and War Nickel inventory. Trusted by investors and collectors since 1977.
Visit Kitco →
Money Metals Exchange
Top-rated dealer for junk silver War Nickel bags at competitive premiums over melt value.
Visit Money Metals →
SD Bullion
Low premiums on War Nickel rolls and bags. Fast shipping and a price match guarantee on bullion products.
Visit SD Bullion →
Silver Gold Bull
Reliable precious metals dealer carrying War Nickels and bullion products. Known for competitive pricing and strong customer service.
Visit Silver Gold Bull →
eBay
The largest marketplace for certified and raw nickel error coins. Use sold listings to gauge real market values before buying.
Shop on eBay →
Amazon
Error coin reference books, loupes, and magnifiers for examining nickel varieties and errors at home.
Shop on Amazon →
FRC Coin Price Guide
Current retail values for Buffalo, Jefferson, and War Nickels across all grades and dates.
View Coin Prices →
Explore More Error Coins
Nickel Error Coins FAQ
What is the most valuable nickel error coin?
The 1918/7-D Buffalo Nickel overdate is generally the most valuable widely recognized nickel error/variety, with high-grade certified examples reaching well into five figures. The famous 1937-D Three-Legged Buffalo is more affordable but still commands strong premiums — from a few hundred dollars in worn grades to $5,000–$10,000+ in mint state. Both require PCGS or NGC certification for serious purchases given the prevalence of altered and counterfeit examples.
How do I identify the 1937-D Three-Legged Buffalo Nickel?
Flip the coin to the reverse and look closely at the bison's legs. On the genuine error, the front right leg is missing entirely — not just weak or worn, but cleanly absent with no ragged stub. This resulted from a Denver Mint employee over-polishing a die to remove clash marks. Because it's the most counterfeited Buffalo Nickel variety, any example being purchased for real money should be independently authenticated by PCGS or NGC.
Are War Nickels worth more than regular Jefferson Nickels?
Yes, as a baseline. War Nickels (1942–1945) are struck in a 35% silver alloy, giving every example a silver melt value floor of roughly $2–$3 regardless of condition — well above a standard nickel's 5-cent face value. Errors on War Nickels combine that silver floor with error and scarcity premiums, so they typically command higher prices than equivalent errors on standard copper-nickel Jefferson issues.
Can I find nickel errors in circulation today?
Jefferson Nickels still circulate actively, and error Jefferson Nickels do surface — particularly from bank rolls. Buffalo Nickels and War Nickels have not circulated meaningfully in decades and are only found through dealers, coin shows, and estate sales. Your best bet for circulation finds is systematically searching Jefferson Nickel bank rolls for doubled dies, off-center strikes, and the 2005 Speared Bison variety.
What's the difference between a die variety and a mint error on nickels?
A die variety (like the 1918/7-D overdate or 1939 Doubled Monticello) results from a specific die being used during production and is consistent across every coin struck by that die. A mint error (like an off-center strike or broadstrike) is a random production accident that affects individual coins. Both are collectible and valuable, but they're categorized and catalogued differently by grading services.
Should I clean my nickel error coin before selling it?
Never clean a coin you intend to sell to collectors. Cleaning removes original mint luster and surface patina, permanently reducing value — often by 50–80% on coins that would otherwise grade well. Collectors and graders can immediately identify cleaned coins, and PCGS and NGC will designate cleaned coins as "Details" grades, which sell at significant discounts to problem-free examples.
Find These Coins on eBayMoney Back Guarantee
'
