Nickel Error Coins: Most Valuable Types & What They're Worth
Nickel error coins span over 150 years of U.S. Mint history — from the legendary 1916 Buffalo Nickel Doubled Die worth $25,000+ to modern Jefferson nickels with doubled dies still found in pocket change. Here's what to look for and what it's worth.
Why Nickel Error Coins Are Worth Collecting
Nickels are one of the best denominations for error coin hunting. They're large enough to show errors clearly, struck in the billions every year (meaning errors escape quality control regularly), and far less intensively searched than cents. Jefferson nickels in particular produce a steady stream of doubled dies, repunched mint marks, and off-center strikes that collectors find in rolls and circulation every year.
The Buffalo Nickel series (1913–1938) is the crown jewel of nickel errors — the 1916 Doubled Die Obverse is one of the most valuable error coins in all of U.S. numismatics, and even common-date Buffalo errors command strong premiums.
Buffalo Nickel Error Coins (1913–1938)
The Buffalo Nickel — also called the Indian Head Nickel — ran for 25 years and produced some of the most celebrated errors in U.S. coin history. The design's high relief and the era's less-precise production methods created ideal conditions for dramatic minting mistakes.
1916 Doubled Die Obverse Rare
The most valuable Buffalo Nickel error and one of the top doubled die coins in all of U.S. numismatics. Dramatic doubling is visible on the date and LIBERTY. In AG-3 the coin is worth $3,000+; in VF it climbs to $25,000 or more. Counterfeits exist — always buy certified.
$3,000 – $25,000+1937-D Three-Legged Buffalo Rare
Not a true mint error but an over-polished die that ground away the buffalo's front right leg. The result is one of the most visually striking and widely recognized U.S. coin varieties. Even heavily worn examples fetch $500+; mint state examples regularly exceed $10,000.
$500 – $10,000+1918/17-D Overdate Rare
A 1917-D die was re-engraved with the date 1918, leaving traces of the 7 visible beneath the 8. One of the great U.S. coin overdates. Clearly visible with a loupe in any grade. Fakes exist — certification is essential before buying or selling.
$1,500 – $20,000+1935 Doubled Die Reverse Scarce
Strong doubling on FIVE CENTS and UNITED STATES OF AMERICA. Less famous than the 1916 DDO but significantly more affordable and still a genuine major error. A good entry point for collectors wanting a dramatic Buffalo Nickel doubled die.
$100 – $2,000+Buffalo Nickel Off-Center Strikes Rare
Off-center Buffalo Nickels are rare survivors — most circulated heavily and were lost or melted. A 20–40% off-center strike with the date visible is a significant find worth $300–$3,000+ depending on centering, grade, and date.
$300 – $3,000+Buffalo Nickel Repunched Mint Marks Common
D and S mint marks on Buffalo Nickels were hand-punched, producing numerous RPM varieties across the series. Major varieties are catalogued in the Cherrypickers' Guide and can add $25–$300+ to otherwise common dates.
$25 – $300+Buffalo Nickel Error Values at a Glance
| Error Coin | G-4 | VG-8 | VF-20 | MS-63 |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1916 DDO KEY | $3,000 | $5,000 | $12,000 | $25,000+ |
| 1937-D Three-Legged | $500 | $750 | $1,500 | $10,000+ |
| 1918/17-D Overdate KEY | $1,500 | $2,500 | $6,000 | $20,000+ |
| 1935 DDR | $100 | $150 | $400 | $2,000+ |
| Off-Center Strike (25%+, date visible) | $200 | $300 | $600 | $3,000+ |
Browse Buffalo Nickel Errors on eBay
See certified and raw Buffalo Nickel error coins with real current market prices.
Browse Buffalo Nickel Errors on eBay Buffalo Nickel GuideJefferson Nickel Error Coins (1938–Present)
Jefferson nickels are one of the best series for finding genuine mint errors in circulation today. Produced in enormous quantities at Philadelphia, Denver, and San Francisco, Jefferson nickels have generated hundreds of documented doubled die varieties, dozens of repunched mint mark varieties, and a steady flow of striking errors — many of which still turn up in bank rolls and pocket change.
1939 Doubled Die Reverse Rare
One of the most dramatic Jefferson Nickel doubled dies. Strong doubling is visible on MONTICELLO, FIVE CENTS, and E PLURIBUS UNUM. The 1939 DDR is the blue-chip Jefferson error — certified examples in MS-65 have sold for over $5,000.
$200 – $5,000+1943-P Doubled Eye Scarce
A wartime silver Jefferson with dramatic doubling visible on Jefferson's eye on the obverse. The "doubled eye" nickname makes this one of the most recognizable and discussed Jefferson varieties. War nickels (1942–1945) contain 35% silver, adding metal value on top of the error premium.
$75 – $1,500+1945-P Doubled Die Reverse Scarce
Strong doubling on MONTICELLO and FIVE CENTS on this wartime silver Jefferson. The 35% silver content provides a floor value, and the doubled die pushes MS examples well above that floor. A popular variety among both error collectors and wartime coinage specialists.
$50 – $800+1954-S/D (S Over D Mint Mark) Scarce
San Francisco over Denver — traces of the D are visible beneath the S mint mark. One of the most widely known mint mark overstrikes in the Jefferson series. Clearly visible under a loupe in any grade and consistently valued by variety collectors.
$30 – $400+1955-D/S (D Over S Mint Mark) Scarce
Denver over San Francisco — the companion to the 1954-S/D. Traces of the S are visible beneath the D. Both the 1954-S/D and 1955-D/S are catalogued in the Cherrypickers' Guide and are standard references for Jefferson variety collectors.
$30 – $300+Jefferson Off-Center Strikes Scarce
Jefferson nickels struck 20–50% off-center are found regularly in bank rolls. With the date visible, a 30%+ off-center Jefferson in circulated condition is worth $50–$200; uncirculated examples push higher. These are among the most accessible dramatic error coins for new collectors.
$30 – $500+Jefferson Broadstrikes Common
Struck without the retaining collar, Jefferson broadstrikes are wider and thinner than normal with no rim. They appear regularly in circulation and rolls. Easy to authenticate and a solid entry-level error coin at $15–$60 depending on grade.
$15 – $60+Jefferson Wrong Planchet Errors Rare
Occasionally a Jefferson nickel is struck on a cent, dime, or foreign planchet. These wrong-planchet errors are among the rarest Jefferson nickel errors — a Jefferson struck on a Lincoln cent planchet (smaller diameter, copper color) is immediately obvious and commands $500–$3,000+ certified.
$500 – $3,000+Jefferson Nickel Error Values by Grade
| Error Coin | VF-20 | EF-40 | MS-63 | MS-65 |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1939 Doubled Die Reverse KEY | $200 | $400 | $1,500 | $5,000+ |
| 1943-P Doubled Eye | $75 | $150 | $500 | $1,500+ |
| 1945-P DDR | $50 | $100 | $300 | $800+ |
| 1954-S/D | $30 | $60 | $150 | $400+ |
| 1955-D/S | $30 | $50 | $125 | $300+ |
| Off-Center Strike (25%+) | $40 | $60 | $150 | $500+ |
| Broadstrike | $15 | $25 | $40 | $60+ |
| Wrong Planchet | $500 | $750 | $1,500 | $3,000+ |
What's Your Jefferson Nickel Error Worth?
Use the free Coin Value Checker for an instant estimate, or see current eBay prices for Jefferson nickel errors.
Free Coin Value Checker Browse Jefferson Nickel Errors on eBayLiberty Head (V) Nickel Error Coins (1883–1912)
Liberty Head nickels are among the oldest commonly collected U.S. nickels, and genuine mint errors on them are legitimately rare. The most famous "error" in the series — the 1913 Liberty Head Nickel — is not a mint error in the traditional sense but a clandestinely struck coin of enormous value. Genuine production errors from the series include off-center strikes and die varieties.
1883 No CENTS Common
Technically a design omission rather than a mint error — the original 1883 V nickels lacked the word CENTS, leading some to gold-plate them and pass them as $5 gold pieces. The Mint added CENTS mid-year. Both varieties are collectible; the No CENTS is more common but still popular.
$15 – $200+Liberty Head Off-Center Strikes Rare
Off-center Liberty Head nickels are genuine rarities. A 20%+ off-center example with the date visible is a significant find at any coin show or estate sale. Values depend on centering and grade, but strong examples regularly top $500 at auction.
$200 – $2,500+Liberty Head Repunched Dates Scarce
Multiple repunched date varieties exist across the Liberty Head series, with the date digits showing secondary impressions from initial punching. Major varieties are catalogued and carry premiums over normal-date examples in comparable grades.
$25 – $400+Shield Nickel Error Coins (1866–1883)
Shield nickels are the earliest U.S. five-cent pieces and were struck during a period of significant die and production experimentation. Genuine errors from this series are rare and command strong collector premiums in any grade.
Shield Nickel Doubled Dies Rare
Multiple doubled die varieties exist for the Shield Nickel series, with some dates showing dramatic doubling on the shield design and motto. These are specialist coins rarely found outside advanced collections and major auction houses.
$200 – $5,000+Shield Nickel Off-Center Strikes Rare
Off-center Shield Nickels are exceptional rarities — the combination of low original survival rates and over 150 years of attrition means genuine examples are significant numismatic discoveries. Most appear through major auction house consignments.
$500 – $8,000+How to Find Nickel Error Coins
Jefferson nickels in bank rolls
Jefferson nickel bank rolls are the most productive hunting ground for modern nickel errors. Request $2 face value rolls (40 coins) from your bank and search systematically. Focus first on checking for off-center strikes and broadstrikes by eye — these are immediately obvious. Then use a loupe to examine dates and motto lettering on older Jeffersons (1938–1970s) for doubled die varieties.
War nickels deserve extra attention
Wartime Jefferson nickels (1942-P through 1945-P) are struck in 35% silver and contain about 0.05626 oz of pure silver each. They're worth $1.50–$2.00 in silver melt value alone, but error varieties on war nickels command substantial premiums. The large P, D, and S mint marks above Monticello make these instantly identifiable. Always pull war nickels from rolls and check them carefully.
Coin shows for Buffalo and older nickels
Buffalo Nickel errors rarely appear in circulation today — they're found through dealer inventories, estate lots, and coin shows. When searching dealer junk boxes, look for Buffalo Nickels with any unusual appearance: missing design elements, dramatically off-center strikes, or obvious doubling. The 1937-D Three-Legged Buffalo can be found this way by collectors who know what they're looking for.
Confirming errors vs. damage
Nickels are durable coins that accumulate decades of wear, bag marks, and environmental damage. A genuine mint error occurs before or during striking — the metal around the error shows normal Mint surfaces. Post-mint damage shows displaced or cut metal with dull surfaces. Any coin where the design looks physically gouged, bent, or corroded is almost certainly damaged, not an error.
Grading and Selling Nickel Error Coins
For nickel errors worth under $100 — common broadstrikes, minor doubled dies, small RPMs — selling raw on eBay is practical and cost-effective. The certification fee would consume a significant portion of the coin's value.
For errors worth $200 or more, PCGS or NGC certification is the right move. Both services grade the coin and describe the error type on the holder. For major Buffalo Nickel varieties like the 1916 DDO, 1937-D Three-Legged, and 1918/17-D overdate, certification is non-negotiable — fakes of all three exist in meaningful numbers, and uncertified examples are viewed with justified skepticism by experienced buyers.
For war nickels with error varieties, NGC and PCGS will note the silver composition on the holder alongside the error designation — a useful selling point that reinforces the coin's dual value as both an error and a silver coin.
Nickel Error Coins FAQ
What is the most valuable nickel error coin?
The 1916 Buffalo Nickel Doubled Die Obverse is the most valuable regularly encountered nickel error, with MS-65 examples selling for $25,000+. The 1918/17-D overdate is close behind at $20,000+ in high grades. For sheer rarity, the 1913 Liberty Head Nickel (five known) has sold for over $4 million, though it's more clandestine strike than traditional mint error.
How do I identify the 1937-D Three-Legged Buffalo Nickel?
Flip the coin to the reverse and look at the buffalo's legs. A normal 1937-D Buffalo Nickel shows four legs. The Three-Legged variety is missing the front right leg — the area where it would be shows flat, polished die surface with no leg definition. The area directly below the missing leg also appears flat. Counterfeits exist made by filing off the leg of a normal coin — on authentic examples, the die surface in that area is smooth and shows original Mint luster, not file marks.
Are war nickels (1942–1945) worth more than regular Jefferson nickels?
Yes — war nickels contain 35% silver, giving them a metal value of roughly $1.50–$2.00 each at current silver prices, well above their 5-cent face value. Error varieties on war nickels carry the same premium over silver value that regular Jefferson errors carry over face value — the 1943-P Doubled Eye, for example, is worth $75–$1,500+ in circulated grades.
Can I find Buffalo Nickel errors in circulation?
Extremely unlikely. Buffalo Nickels haven't circulated meaningfully since the 1950s and have been heavily searched by collectors for decades. Your realistic sources for Buffalo Nickel errors are coin shows, dealer inventory, online auctions, and estate sales. When buying any high-value Buffalo Nickel variety, always insist on PCGS or NGC certification.
What Jefferson nickel errors can I realistically find in pocket change?
Minor doubled dies on 1950s–1970s Jeffersons are occasionally found in bank rolls. Broadstrikes and small off-center strikes appear in circulation regularly. The most exciting realistic find is a war nickel (1942–1945) with a minor doubled die variety — these still turn up in unsearched roll lots purchased from small banks and credit unions.
Do repunched mint marks add significant value to Jefferson nickels?
Major RPM varieties on key or semi-key dates can add $30–$400+ over normal coin value. On common dates, the premium is smaller — typically $10–$50 for clearly visible repunching. The Cherrypickers' Guide (Flynn) is the standard reference for Jefferson RPM varieties and lists all known examples with photos and value information.
Explore More Error Coins
Check Current Nickel Values
See what Buffalo Nickels and Jefferson nickels are selling for across all grades and dates.
View All Coin Prices Free Coin Value Checker
'
